• Menu
  • Skip to right header navigation
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to secondary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Before Header

Call us now  07 4688 2188

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Clifford Gouldson Lawyers

  • About
    • Our Origin Story
    • Our Manifesto
    • Our Future
    • CGLaw COVID Protocol
    • Toowoomba
    • Brisbane
    • Sunshine Coast
  • Careers
  • Community
    • 2021 Artist in Residence Program
  • Contact Us
  • Search
  • About
    • Our Origin Story
    • Our Manifesto
    • Our Future
    • CGLaw COVID Protocol
    • Toowoomba
    • Brisbane
    • Sunshine Coast
  • Careers
  • Community
    • 2021 Artist in Residence Program
  • Contact Us
  • Search

Mobile Menu

  • Our Team
  • Practice Areas
  • Knowledge
  • Events
  • Industries
  • For Individuals
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • Our Team
  • Practice Areas
  • Knowledge
  • Events
  • Industries
  • For Individuals

Second COVID insurance test case won by insurers

You are here: Home / News / Second COVID insurance test case won by insurers

The Federal Court has handed down its ruling in the second test case concerning whether insurance policies for “business interruption or interference” (BII) cover COVID-19 related loss, including any loss of trade caused by government restrictions.

Justice Jagot ordered in favour of Allianz, Chubb, Guild, Insurance Australia, QBE and Swiss Re preferring a narrow interpretation of the policy terms, requiring a direct connection between the COVID-19 outbreaks, the business premises and government restrictions causing a loss of trade.

The Court’s narrow interpretation means the anticipated flood of litigation against BII insurers is unlikely.  A business will not be indemnified unless it can prove COVID-19, or any organism related to COVID-19, at its premises or within a specified radius of the premises was the cause of the government action that resulted in BII.

The Federal Court also took the chance to confirm any exclusions in BII policies for quarantinable diseases under the previous Quarantine Act 1908 (Cth) (Quarantine Act) do not apply as COVID-19 is not such a disease.  This clarification is important as insurers considered appealing against the first test case (see our previous alert here) where it was ruled insurers could not rely on exclusion clauses referring to the Quarantine Act to avoid payouts as these exclusions were of no effect because the Quarantine Act was repealed and replaced with the Biosecurity Act 2015 (Cth).

Although the circumstances in which businesses can claim BII compensation was narrowed, all parties were granted permissions to appeal the decision.

If any compensation is payable under a BII policy for COVID-19 related loss, such compensation must be reduced by any previously received relief (e.g. lower rent) as ultimately, such relief will have lessened the cost of interruption or interference to the business.

If you need any assistance claiming under your BII policy, then our experienced Litigation + Dispute Resolution team can help. 

If you’re a landlord who is interested in advice concerning repercussions for arrangements with your tenants, then our experienced Commercial + Property team can help. 


For further information please contact Harrison Humphries, Section Head.

The assistance of Jade Scheuerle, Law Clerk in researching this article is gratefully acknowledged.

Previous Post: « COVID-19 workplace vaccination policies – FAQs
Next Post: Stretching fabric and the truth: Lorna Jane cops $5 million in penalties »

Primary Sidebar

We can help

Amanda Tolson

Director

Harrison Humphries

Director

Brian Conrick

Senior Consultant

Carly Brailak

Special Counsel

Michelle Kelly

Senior Associate

Lisa Hooper

Lawyer

Agnes Derrick

Lawyer

Oliver Dornbusch

Lawyer

Sally Fraser

Conveyancing Paralegal

Alison Cassidy

Paralegal

Tracey Gust

Paralegal

Carol Redgen

Conveyancing Paralegal

Heath Knox

Commercial + Property Paralegal

Maddison Klingner

Legal Secretary

Related Alerts

June 22, 2022
Incorporated association rules change today with more to follow – how is your organisation impacted?

We recently published a legal alert regarding amendments to the Associations Incorporation Act 1981 (Qld)...

June 7, 2022
Fair Work upholds decision to dismiss for IP disclosure  

A recent decision of the Fair Work Commission to uphold the dismissal under the...

May 31, 2022
I am selling my business, but what about the employees?

Selling or purchasing a business is an exciting milestone in any business owner’s career....

View other alerts

Footer

Clifford Gouldson Lawyers

CLIFFORD GOULDSON LAWYERS
P: 07 4688 2188
F: 07 4688 2199
mail@cglaw.com.au
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Locations

TOOWOOMBA (Head Office)
Level 1, 610 Ruthven Street,
Toowooomba Q 4350

PO Box 8208,
Toowoomba South Q 4350

Toowoomba Office

BRISBANE
Suite 1805, Level 18,
239 George Street,
Brisbane Q 4000

PO Box 12802 George Street,
Brisbane Q 4003

Brisbane Office

 

SUNSHINE COAST
L1, Regatta Corporate Building,
2 Innovation Parkway,
Birtinya Q 4575

Locked Bag 5010
Caloundra DC Q 4551

Sunshine Coast Office

Practice Areas

  • Wills, Estates, Planning + Structuring
  • Workplace
  • Litigation + Dispute Resolution
  • Commercial + Property
  • Construction
  • Intellectual Property
  • Privacy & Disclaimer
  • Terms of Use

Site Footer

CG Law (Trading) Pty Ltd ACN 143 426 028 t/a Clifford Gouldson Lawyers ABN 89 143 426 028 Liability limited by a scheme approved under professional standards legislation..

Copyright © 2022 Clifford Gouldson Lawyers · Privacy & Disclaimer · Terms of Use · Marketing by John Gray Marketing · Site by Kingfisher