Clifford Gouldson Lawyers

PPSR Case Study: ABN vs ACN

Print Version

6/10/2017

In a case* involving a disputed Personal Property Security Register (PPSR) matter it was made clear that a mistake as simple as using an ABN instead of an ACN is enough for a company to lose their secured interest.

Alleasing Pty Ltd (Alleasing), as Lessor, had entered into a leasing agreement with OneSteel Manufacturing Pty Ltd (OneSteel) for machinery and various equipment. Alleasing proceeded to register its security interest over the leased equipment as the secured party on the PPSR.

During the process of registration Alleasing mistakenly registered its interests over OneSteel’s ABN and not its ACN.

The ‘what-if’ scenario arose when OneSteel entered into voluntary administration and the administrators discovered Alleasing’s defective registration. The Administrators argued registrations were in fact unperfected.

OneSteel argued that in accordance with section 164 and 165(b) of the Personal Properties Securities Act 2009 (Cth) (PPSA) Alleasing’s registration was defective due to the serial number of the equipment not being recorded and conversely, recording no ACN had created an inability for other creditors to search the register and see Alleasing’s registered interest. 

Justice Brereton found a distinction exists between ABNs and ACNs as provided for within the PPSA, even in circumstances where an ABN includes the nine digit ACN.

His Honour concluded the absence of an ACN in the registrations amounted to a serious misleading defect and consequently Alleasing’s registrations were void and they lost ownership of the equipment.

If you require advice on PPSR matters please contact our Commercial + Property team.

LATEST NEWS/EVENTS

Shadow and De Facto Directors: When you’re a director and didn’t know it! - 13/10/2017

Can you face the risks of being a director of a corporation even when you aren’t formally a director? In short, the answer is yes, if you are found to be a de facto or shadow director.... read on

Workplace comments: When shooting from the hip, hits your foot! - 11/10/2017

We all know managing employees can be a difficult and sometimes hazardous time for employers and employees.... read on

Insolvent trading reform - smoother sailing for company directors - 14/09/2017

This week, amendments to the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (‘the Act’) were passed to eliminate personal civil liability of company directors in certain circumstances.... read on

Read all news/events

Site Developed by FAQ Interactive